Body image is commonly linked to our self esteem, as such it is a contentious issue that provokes much heated debate amongst men, and more particularly, women, across the globe. When it comes to our bodies, one must consider the question: should anyone apart from ourselves have an opinion on what size we are? Because the issue of body image is also intrinsically linked to our overall health, medical professionals have often weighed in on the issue, urging us to observe a healthy lifestyle in order to avoid ill-health. Nutritionists and personal trainers exist to advise us on how to best work towards adopting a healthier diet and sculpting a leaner body. However, there are also many businesses that thrive on the desire that some men and women have to achieve an unrealistically slim body without adhering to the more sustainable lifestyle techniques such as healthy eating and regular exercise. There are crash diet plans, appetite suppressant pills and meal replacement programs. Procedures such as liposuction and gastric band surgery are more extreme examples of the lengths some people are going to in order to achieve what they perceive to be a more idealistic body.
Of course, one would be remiss in not mentioning the contribution of media to the body image issue. Women's fashion magazines often reinforce the idea that slim equals beautiful, whether purposely or otherwise. To the same affect, celebrities too have been known promote embracing ones own body at any size; such as evidenced in a recent article on Australian Idol winner Casey Donovan who exclaimed she loved her "killer curves". Similarly, Beth Ditto exhibited her comfort as a larger woman when she posed naked on the cover of Love magazine. Extremism on either end of the body image debate is almost certainly detrimental to ones health - so how can a person establish a strong sense of what is best when it comes to their own body, without feeling pressure and inadequacy?
An important consideration to acknowledge is there is no body image norm, nor should there be, we are all built differently.
We were not all built to pull on a size 0 and look like Jennifer Hawkins or Miranda Kerr, nor were we all made with curves to rival the likes of Kate Winslet or Nigella Lawson. But then, this is why the body image debate is so topical - because we have made it an argument based around how we look, often comparatively, not how we feel.
Christina Hendricks, Kate Moennig.
So, while there is no such thing as a "normal" body type, there is an average body size. In Australia, this average size of women is on the rise, with recent studies confirming that Australian women are getting fatter, faster. Earlier this year, there was national controversy about the use of Australian model Jennifer Hawkins on the cover of Marie Claire magazine. Many Australian women objected, claiming that Hawkins was not indicative of a 'real woman' or the average Australian woman. And with the average size currently sitting at around size 14-16, these women are correct, Hawkins is not average. But would a woman who merely ticks the box of being that "average" size, be a more positive body image role model for women? This is where the argument becomes complicated. Should we allow the justification of our size by comparative means, based on the fact that a majority of woman around us look similarly, or should we go further and question the average or perceived "norm" and attempt to discover what is best on an individual level?
Jennifer Hudson, Miranda Kerr.
Justification of our body based on the size of others should be irrelevant, though for many women, it is not. We compare our bodies to that of our friends, classmates, coworkers, celebrities, models and the general public. In order to achieve a healthy attitude towards our bodies, we must move away from this sort of comparison. We must also recognise that our self worth is not derived from the size of our waist. We can achieve a more positive attitude towards our bodies by acknowledging that body image is a health issue, not an aesthetic issue. To this end, we should focus on achieving our own healthy body, rather than attempting to emulate what may be healthy for our best friend, or a celebrity we admire.
So how does one determine their bodies comfortable healthy size? We can start by forgetting about fad diets, regular rapid detox plans, diet pills, surgery or unhealthy workout obsessions - similarly, we should forget about eating takeout four times a week, constantly snacking throughout the day on unhealthy foods or soft drinks or doing little to no exercise in a week. To find what size your body is comfortable plateauing at, one must observe what is widely acknowledged to be a healthy lifestyle - eating predominantly healthy meals at appropriate portion sizes and exercising at least 3 to 4 times a week, doing both cardio and resistance training.
When you know how your body looks and feels when healthy, this is the norm to which you should compare your body going forward. If eating a healthy diet and regular exercise does not get your body to the point at which you believe is optimal for your health, you should consult a nutritionist to ensure your diet contains all the vital ingredients that are necessary to obtain best health, and a personal trainer who can tailor a custom work-out plan. You can additionally consult a General Practitioner who can help uncover any underlying health issues that may be blocking your progress.
In the end, you may find that your comfortable healthy weight is a size 16, or maybe it's a size 8. By being aware of what weight or size your body is most comfortable at when observing a healthy lifestyle, you are able to move away from rationalising or hiding behind slim pride, fat acceptance or national average solidarity.
This is a loaded topic, please be constructive in sharing your thoughts. How do you feel about the body image debate? Are you happy with your body? If you're not, what would make you happy?
Labels: big issues, life in general, style and beauty
9 Comments:
- At 12 February 2010 at 19:55 , Fiona said...
-
I'm generally happier with my body now that I have been in years. Mostly I think this is because it started to fight back at all the crap I was doing to it - bad foods, or not enough foods, etc etc. and I got ill. Finally I'm sorting myself out and listening to it more.
I'm a size 12, and technically about 3 kilos overweight. I can see where that few can go from, but if I'm feeling healthy and getting fitter then I'm happy. - At 13 February 2010 at 07:39 , Scribbles said...
-
Thanks for that Kate, I agree with what you say. As a tall girl built with hips that my gynae says "will just slide a baby right out", I know I'm never going to be a Size 10 - I'll be a Size 12 if I am lucky and with my curves it's always going to be damn awkward to find pants. The reality is, though, at the moment my size dresses me - I know there are certain options in clothing that I shouldn't wear because of the size of my body. I'd really like that to change. I'd also like to feel more fit and healthy and that is part of the reason for losing the weight I want to this year. Exercise is a bit of a challenge right now as I try to pack a house in less than a week but I look at it as getting lots of strength training! I hope to make my goal by the end of the year (which will still leave me in the overweight category), but even if it takes me slightly longer, I know now that I'm on the right track.
- At 13 February 2010 at 13:28 , marzipan said...
-
fantastic post! and such a hard topic... i feel like loving my body is something that i have to work daily, and it helps to wake up with the intent to feed my body some good food, move it around a little, and dress in something that makes it feel comfortable/attractive. that way, i'm able to stave off the "i ate so much i feel like dying" or "these are the only jeans clean, but they are a size too small so i want to kill myself all day long" type issues and deal with only the most major hiccups along the way.
xo. - At 13 February 2010 at 16:34 , nessbow said...
-
I'm a petite lady. I'm rather short and very slim. I suffered from an eating disorder during high school and I have now recovered. I am within the healthy weight range for my height, I am really happy with my body and grateful for all the things it can do. My flexibility is fantastic and I can dance all night, I have so much energy and now have a healthy relationship with food.
It bothers me when people use the "real woman" tag to label women who are a size 12 and over. I'm totally real. I eat a healthy diet (although i do indulge in a sweet treat every now and then) and I exercise moderately throughout the week. This is the way my body looks naturally, when it is taken care of but not abused, and I am really happy with it. My body is just as real and beautiful as any curvier woman, and it's sad that just because I'm on the thin side, I should be made to feel guilty and somehow worth less than a curvier lady. - At 13 February 2010 at 21:59 , said...
-
I definitely needed to read this right now! I love the sentence:
"...because we have made it an argument based around how we look, often comparatively, not how we feel."
If I compare myself to others I'm never happy. If I go with how I feel, then everything is easier. And if I'm not happy about my body it should only be because I'm not treating it the way I should, NOT because I'm holding myself up to compare against someone else. (Easier said than done of course). - At 14 February 2010 at 00:11 , said...
-
Thank you so much for your comment on my blog! <3 It made me really happy and it means a lot to me. :)
Unfortunately, I don't have time right now to read this post but I'll definitely do that tomorrow. Your blog seems wonderful! And the fact that you like David Tennant is definitely a plus. ;)
xoxo
Vanessa - At 14 February 2010 at 00:12 , said...
-
Yes, there is far too much negative press today regarding body image. I am tired of people bitching at Nigella for being curvaceous. They just can't stand the fact she is happy with herself (hopefully, anyway).
Gala Darling wrote an article on weight and suggested to throw away your scales & base your happiness on how well you feel in yourself, and also see how well your clothes fit and adjust your eating/exercising regime accordingly, which I think is a brilliant attitude to adopt towards weight.
Life is more than just being a number, whether it be salary, status, or weight. - At 16 February 2010 at 10:05 , L said...
-
Thank you so, so much for this post! I completely agree — it's about how you feel inside (as well as healthy weight parameters of course.) And I agree with nessbow; I'm seeing a lot of "fashion doesn't like skinny anymore" "curves are in" and that's great but, what about those of us who are naturally on the thin side and (un)fortunately not blessed with a lot of boobage etc? It can be just as hurtful to be called skinny in my opinion, and it bothers me when people say that because there is a stereotype attached to that as well (like she probably doesn't eat, she's bulimic, she's probably trying too hard...)
I myself have been quite thin since I was little, and I've always wanted to be a bit curvier because most people in my family are, and I guess as my background is Latin the shapelier you are the more womanly you are, so sometimes even my own family's comments can be hurtful. I don't know if I'm explaining myself very well. Either way, I've reached a point where I've accepted my weight; I've been to the doctors and all my levels of everything are fine and I'm in a healthy weight range. So now all I have to do is be happy with myself and work with what I have! - At 16 February 2010 at 21:42 , Alicia - Sea Of Ghosts said...
-
Really well written, Kate. I completely agree. I am sick of seeing body types as fashion trends.
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
Post a Comment